It's an arbitrary label. It creates a polarity between The Gifted and The Non-Gifted where there is no natural distinction. It increases a sense of isolation in a population of children already prone to feeling different and isolated from their peers; it serves to increase envy in those not falling into the category, children already prone to feeling envious of those that do. It can create a sense of superiority in those it's applied to, and enhance a sense of entitlement that creates a complex of emotional issues. Gifted is an antiquated term; it carries a 1970's ring to it. A more interesting set of questions is: Why is the term Gifted necessary? What do we gain from using it? Are there there any alternative ways to think about our unique children? See here for more.